2016 Judicial Performance Evaluations | Colorado Office of Judicial Performance Evaluation Home

Need help with accessibility? Click the link for more information - Accessibility Page

2016 Evaluations

Please click on your county below to find the district and county judges, if any, standing for retention in your judicial district. Your ballot will also include all appellate judges standing for retention.

View the full list of judges standing for retention in 2016

Appellate Courts

Honorable William Hood

Retain

Honorable Karen M. Ashby	Retain
Honorable Michael H. Berger	Retain
Honorable Steven L. Bernard	Retain
Honorable Stephanie E. Dunn	Retain
Honorable David Furman	Retain
Honorable Robert D. Hawthorne	Retain
Honorable Jerry N. Jones	Retain
Honorable Anthony J. Navarro	Retain
Honorable Gilbert M. Román	Retain
Honorable Diana Terry	Retain

Click on your county below to view the judges on your ballot

Seventeenth Judicial District (Adams County)

District Judges
Honorable Patrick T. Murphy	Retain
Honorable Emily Elizabeth Anderson	Retain
Honorable Thomas R. Ensor	Retain
Honorable F. Michael Goodbee	Retain
Honorable Jill-Ellyn Straus	Does Not Retain

Adams County Judges
Honorable Leroy D. Kirby	Retain

Twelfth Judicial District (Alamosa County)

District Judges
Honorable Martin A. Gonzales	Retain

Alamosa County Judges
No Alamosa county court judges standing for retention

Eighteenth Judicial District (Arapahoe County)

District Judges
Honorable Carlos Armando Samour Jr.	Retain
Honorable Natalie T. Chase	Retain
Honorable Jeffrey K. Holmes	Retain
Honorable Frederick Thomas Martinez	Retain
Honorable David John Stevens	Retain
Honorable Elizabeth Ann Weishaupl	Retain

Arapahoe County Judges
Honorable Anne M. Ollada	Retain

Sixth Judicial District (Archuleta County)

District Judges
Honorable William L. Herringer	Retain
Honorable Jeffery Raymond Wilson	Retain

Archuleta County Judges
No Archuleta county court judges standing for retention

Fifteenth Judicial District (Baca County)

District Judges
Honorable Stanley A. Brinkley	Retain

Baca County Judges
No Baca county court judges standing for retention

Sixteenth Judicial District (Bent County)

District Judges
Honorable Mark A. MacDonnell	Retain
Honorable Michael Andrew Schiferl	Do Not Retain

Bent County Judges
Honorable Samuel Scott Vigil	Retain

Twentieth Judicial District (Boulder County)

District Judges
Honorable Andrew Hartman	Retain
Honorable Bruce Langer	Retain

Boulder County Judges
No Boulder county court judges standing for retention

Seventeenth Judicial District (Broomfield County)

District Judges
Honorable Patrick T. Murphy	Retain
Honorable Emily Elizabeth Anderson	Retain
Honorable Katherine Delgado	Retain
Honorable Thomas R. Ensor	Retain
Honorable F. Michael Goodbee	Retain
Honorable Jill-Ellyn Straus	Do Not Retain

Broomfield County Judges
No Boulder county court judges standing for retention

Eleventh Judicial District (Chaffee County)

District Judges
Honorable Patrick William Murphy	Retain
Honorable Stephan A. Groome	Retain

Chaffee County Judges
Honorable William P. Alderton	Retain

Fifteenth Judicial District (Cheyenne County)

District Judges
Honorable Stanley A. Brinkley	Retain

Cheyenne County Judges
No Cheyenne county court judges standing for retention

Fifth Judicial District (Clear Creek County)

District Judges
Honorable Paul R. Dunkelman	Retain
Honorable Wayne Patton	Retain
Honorable Karen Ann Romeo	Retain

Clear Creek County Judges
Honorable Rachel J. Olguin-Fresquez	Retain

Twelfth Judicial District (Conejos County)

District Judges
Honorable Martin A. Gonzales	Retain

Conejos County Judges
No Conejos county court judges standing for retention

Twelfth Judicial District (Costilla County)

District Judges
Honorable Martin A. Gonzales	Retain

Costilla County Judges
No Costilla county court judges standing for retention

Sixteenth Judicial District (Crowley County)

District Judges
Honorable Mark A. MacDonnell	Retain
Honorable Michael Andrew Schiferl	Do Not Retain

Crowley County Judges
No Crowley county court judges standing for retention	Retain

Eleventh Judicial District (Custer County)

District Judges
Honorable Patrick William Murphy	Retain
Honorable Stephan A. Groome	Retain

Custer County Judges
No Custer county court judges standing for retention

Seventh Judicial District (Delta County)

District Judges
No district court judges standing for retention.

Delta County Judges
Honorable Sandra K. Miller	Retain

Second Judicial District (Denver County)

District Judges
Honorable Michael A. Martinez	Retain
Honorable Karen L. Brody	Retain
Honorable Edward David Bronfin	Retain
Honorable Ross B. H. Buchanan	Retain
Honorable Kandace C. Gerdes	Retain
Honorable Andy McCallin	Retain
Honorable William D. Robbins	Retain
Honorable Brian Whitney	Retain
Honorable D. Brett Woods	Retain
Honorable Laurie A. Clark	Retain
Honorable Donna J. Schmalberger	Retain

Denver County Judges
Honorable John M. Marcucci	Retain
Honorable Doris E. Burd	Retain
Honorable Beth A. Faragher	Retain
Honorable Gary M. Jackson	Retain
Honorable Nicole M. Rodarte	Retain
Honorable Andre L. Rudolph	Retain
Honorable Theresa A. Spahn	Retain

Twenty-Second Judicial District (Dolores County)

District Judges
Honorable Douglas S. Walker	Retain

Chaffee County Judges
Honorable E. Dale Boyd	Retain

Eighteenth Judicial District (Douglas County)

District Judges
Honorable Carlos Armando Samour Jr.	Retain
Honorable Natalie T. Chase	Retain
Honorable Jeffrey K. Holmes	Retain
Honorable Frederick Thomas Martinez	Retain
Honorable David John Stevens	Retain
Honorable Elizabeth Ann Weishaupl	Retain

Douglas County Judges
No Douglas county court judges standing for retention

Fifth Judicial District (Eagle County)

District Judges
Honorable Paul R. Dunkelman	Retain
Honorable Wayne Patton	Retain
Honorable Karen Ann Romeo	Retain

Eagle County Judges
Honorable Katherine T. Sullivan	Retain

Fourth Judicial District (El Paso County)

District Judges
Honorable Gilbert Anthony Martinez	Retain
Honorable Robin Lynn Chittum	Retain
Honorable David A. Gilbert	Retain
Honorable Deborah J. Grohs	Retain
Honorable G. David Miller	Retain
Honorable Marla Prudek	Retain

El Paso County Judges
Honorable Laura Norris Findorff	Retain
Honorable Karla J. Hansen	Retain
Honroable Daniel S. Wilson	Retain

Eighteenth Judicial District (Elbert County)

District Judges
Honorable Carlos Armando Samour Jr.	Retain
Honorable Natalie T. Chase	Retain
Honorable Jeffrey K. Holmes	Retain
Honorable Frederick Thomas Martinez	Retain
Honorable David John Stevens	Retain
Honorable Elizabeth Ann Weishaupl	Retain

Elbert County Judges
No Elbert county court judges standing for retention

Eleventh Judicial District (Chaffee County)

District Judges
Honorable Patrick William Murphy	Retain
Honorable Stephan A. Groome	Retain

Chaffee County Judges
Honorable William P. Anderson	Retain

Ninth Judicial District (Garfield County)

District Judges
Honorable John Fowler Neiley	Retain

Garfield County Judges
No Garfield county court judges standing for retention

First Judicial District (Gilpin County)

District Judges
Honorable Philip James McNulty	Retain
Honorable Dennis J. Hall	Retain
Honorable Jeffery Ralph Pilkington	Retain
Honorable Todd L. Vriesman	Retain

Gilpin County Judges
No Gilpin county court judges standing for retention

Fourteenth Judicial District (Grand County)

District Judges
Honorable Mary C. Hoak	Retain

Grand County Judges
No Grand county court judges standing for retention

Seventh Judicial District (Gunnison County)

District Judges
No district court judges standing for retention.

Gunnison County Judges
No Gunnison county court judges standing for retention

Seventh Judicial District (Hinsdale County)

District Judges
No district court judges standing for retention.

Hinsdale County Judges
Honorable Alvin K. Lutz	Retain

Third Judicial District (Huerfano County)

District Judges
Honorable Leslie J. Gerbracht	Retain

Huerfano County Judges
No Huerfano county court judges standing for retention

Eighth Judicial District (Jackson County)

District Judges
Honorable Caroll Michelle Brinegar	Retain
Honorable Gregory M. Lammons	Retain

Jackson County Judges
No Jackson county court judges standing for retention

First Judicial District (Jefferson County)

District Judges
Honorable Philip James McNulty	Retain
Honorable Dennis J. Hall	Retain
Honorable Jeffery Ralph Pilkington	Retain
Honorable Todd L. Vriesman	Retain

Jefferson County Judges
Honorable Bradley Allen Burback	Retain
Honorable Verna L. Carpenter	Retain
Honorable Tammy Greene	Retain
Honorable K.J. Moore	Retain

Fifteenth Judicial District (Kiowa County)

District Judges
Honorable Stanley A. Brinkley	Retain

Kiowa County Judges
No Kiowa county court judges standing for retention

Thirteenth Judicial District (Kit Carson County)

District Judges
No district court judges standing for retention.

Kit Carson County Judges
No Kit Carson county court judges standing for retention

Sixth Judicial District (La Plata County)

District Judges
Honorable William L. Herringer	Retain
Honorable Jeffery Raymond Wilson	Retain

La Plata County Judges
No La Plata county court judges standing for retention

Fifth Judicial District (Lake County)

District Judges
Honorable Paul R. Dunkelman	Retain
Honorable Wayne Patton	Retain
Honorable Karen Ann Romeo	Retain

Lake County Judges
Honorable Jonathan Shamis	Retain

Eighth Judicial District (Larimer County)

District Judges
Honorable Caroll Michelle Brinegar	Retain
Honorable Gregory M. Lammons	Retain

Larimer County Judges
Honorable Mary Joan Berenato	Retain
Honorable Kraig Ecton	Retain
Honorable Joshua B. Lehman	Retain

Third Judicial District (Las Animas County)

District Judges
Honorable Leslie J. Gerbracht	Retain

Huerfano County Judges
No Las Animas county court judges standing for retention

Eighteenth Judicial District (Lincoln County)

District Judges
Honorable Carlos Armando Samour Jr.	Retain
Honorable Natalie T. Chase	Retain
Honorable Jeffrey K. Holmes	Retain
Honorable Frederick Thomas Martinez	Retain
Honorable David John Stevens	Retain
Honorable Elizabeth Ann Weishaupl	Retain

Lincoln County Judges
No Lincoln county court judges standing for retention

Thirteenth Judicial District (Logan County)

District Judges
No district court judges standing for retention.

Logan County Judges
Honorable Ray Ann Brammer	Retain

Twenty-First Judicial District (Mesa County)

District Judges
Honorable Richard T. Gurley	Retain
Honorable Valerie J. Robison	Retain

Mesa County Judges
Honorable Craig P. Henderson	Retain
Honorable Gretchen B. Larson	Retain

Twelfth Judicial District (Mineral County)

District Judges
Honorable Martin A. Gonzales	Retain

Mineral County Judges
Honorable Ruth M. Acheson	Retain

Fourteenth Judicial District (Moffat County)

District Judges
Honorable Mary C. Hoak	Retain

Moffat County Judges
No Moffat county court judges standing for retention

Twenty-Second Judicial District (Montezuma County)

District Judges
Honorable Douglas S. Walker	Retain

Montezuma County Judges
No Montezuma county court judges standing for retention.	Retain

Seventh Judicial District (Montrose County)

District Judges
No district court judges standing for retention.

Montrose County Judges
No Montrose county judges standing for retention.

Thirteenth Judicial District (Morgan County)

District Judges
No district court judges standing for retention.

Morgan County Judges
No Morgan county judges standing for retention.

Sixteenth Judicial District (Otero County)

District Judges
Honorable Mark A. MacDonnell	Retain
Honorable Michael Andrew Schiferl	Do Not Retain

Otero County Judges
No Otero county court judges standing for retention.

Seventh Judicial District (Ouray County)

District Judges
No district court judges standing for retention.

Ouray County Judges
No Ouray county court judges standing for retention.

Thirteenth Judicial District (Phillips County)

District Judges
No district court judges standing for retention.

Ouray County Judges
Honorable Kimbra Leigh Killin	Retain

Thirteenth Judicial District (Phillips County)

District Judges
No district court judges standing for retention.

Phillips County Judges
Honorable Kimbra Leigh Killin	Retain

Ninth Judicial District (Pitkin County)

District Judges
Honorable John Fowler Neiley	Retain

Pitkin County Judges
No Pitkin county court judges standing for retention

Fifteenth Judicial District (Prowers County)

District Judges
Honorable Stanley A. Brinkley	Retain

Prowers County Judges
No Prowers county court judges standing for retention

Tenth Judicial District (Pueblo County)

District Judges
Honorable Thomas B. Flesher	Retain
Honorable Jill S. Mattoon	Retain
Honorable Larry Charles Schwartz	Retain

Pueblo County Judges
No Pueblo county court judges standing for retention

Ninth Judicial District (Rio Blanco County)

District Judges
Honorable John Fowler Neiley	Retain

Rio Blanco County Judges
Honorable Laurie Noble	Retain

Twelfth Judicial District (Rio Grande County)

District Judges
Honorable Martin A. Gonzales	Retain

Rio Grande County Judges
No Rio Grande county court judges standing for retention.

Fourteenth Judicial District (Routt County)

District Judges
Honorable Mary C. Hoak	Retain

Routt County Judges
No Routt county court judges standing for retention.

Twelfth Judicial District (Saguache County)

District Judges
Honorable Martin A. Gonzales	Retain

Saguache County Judges
No Saguache county court judges standing for retention.

Sixth Judicial District (San Juan County)

District Judges
Honorable William L. Herringer	Retain
Honorable Jeffery Raymond Wilson	Retain

San Juan County Judges
Honorable Anthony Douglas Edwards	Retain

Seventh Judicial District (San Miguel County)

District Judges
No district court judges standing for retention.

San Miguel County Judges
No San Miguel county court judges standing for retention.

Thirteenth Judicial District (Sedgwick County)

District Judges
No district court judges standing for retention.

Sedgwick County Judges
Honorable Tera Neugebauer	Retain

Fifth Judicial District (Summit County)

District Judges
Honorable Paul R. Dunkelman	Retain
Honorable Wayne Patton	Retain
Honorable Karen Ann Romeo	Retain

Summit County Judges
Honorable Edward Jude Casis	Retain

Fourth Judicial District (Teller County)

District Judges
Honorable Gilbert Anthony Martinez	Retain
Honorable Robin Lynn Chittum	Retain
Honorable David A. Gilbert	Retain
Honorable Deborah J. Grohs	Retain
Honorable G. David Miller	Retain
Honorable Marla Prudek	Retain

Teller County Judges
No Teller county court judges standing for retention.

Thirteenth Judicial District (Washington County)

District Judges
No district judges standing for retention.

Washington County Judges
No Washington county court judges standing for retention.

Thirteenth Judicial District (Weld County)

District Judges
Honorable Warren Troy Hause	Retain
Honorable Julie C. Hoskins	Retain
Honorable Shannon D. Lyons	Retain
Honorable Thomas J. Quammen	Retain

Weld County Judges
No Weld county court judges standing for retention.

Thirteenth Judicial District (Yuma County)

District Judges
No district judges standing for retention.

Yuma County Judges
No Yuma county court judges standing for retention.