Need help with accessibility? Click the link for more information - Accessibility Page

1

Gerhart, Shannon Marie 2024 Evaluation

#FFFFFF

Fourth Judicial District - El Paso County Court Judge

Honorable Shannon Marie Gerhart

Retention Year: 2024
Recommendation: Meets Performance Standards

Reports: 

2024 Retention Survey Report (PDF) 

2023 Interim Survey Report (PDF)

 

Need an accessible PDF Document Version?

Please click on the link below and email our staff

Contact Us

The Fourth Judicial District Commission on Judicial Performance voted 7-0 with three absent that Judge Shannon Marie Gerhart MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS

Based upon interviews, surveys, and observations by the commission, Judge Gerhart has performed exceedingly well as a County Court judge. She has demonstrated excellent judicial temperament, and consistently manages an efficient docket, 94 percent of which are either traffic or misdemeanor cases. The remaining six percent are a mix of civil, juvenile and criminal. She regularly assists other judges, filling in to provide relief for their dockets. Judge Gerhart efficiently responds to court requests, rendering decisions and orders promptly. She also is committed to ensuring all people in her courtroom, whether attorney, non-attorney, plaintiff or defendant, are all treated equally, with respect and dignity. Judge Gerhart has routinely filed all required financial disclosures and has no record of judicial discipline.

The Commission reviewed Judge Gerhart’s performance by observing her in court, reading samples of her written orders, examining surveys submitted by attorneys and non-attorneys who had appeared in her courtroom, reviewing her self-evaluation, and interviewing the Chief Judge, District Attorney and Public Defender. The Commission also conducted an in-person interview with her. The Commission discussed her self-evaluation and asked for her reflection on specific comments from survey respondents. Some of the positive comments included references to Judge Gerhart’s professionalism, her willingness to mentor young attorneys and her firm, but fair demeanor in the courtroom. While there were some negative comments, the Commission found that overall Judge Gerhart is doing an excellent job. The Commission also discussed with Judge Gerhart her appellate record. Judge Gerhart’s overall combined score on the 2024 Judicial Performance Survey was 3.2 out of 4.0. There is concern among the commissioners that the relatively small number of survey respondents, only 9 attorneys and 22 non-attorneys out of over 900 surveys circulated, makes the scoring statistically invalid.  The Commission thus relied primarily upon comments, interviews and actual observations of Judge Gerhart in the courtroom. The 31 people who did respond overwhelmingly stated that Judge Gerhart meets performance standards.

Judge Gerhart has served as a County Court Judge since March 2017. She attended undergraduate school at the University of Northern Iowa and law school at the University of Oklahoma. She started her career at the District Attorney’s Office as an intern during her first and second years of law school. After passing the bar, she was offered a position as a County Court District Attorney and was quickly promoted to the County Court Floater District Attorney. In 2003, she was promoted to District Court, was promoted to senior DA in 2004, and served as the County Court Senior DA and Juvenile Court Senior DA from 2004 through 2010. She was promoted to Chief Deputy District Attorney in 2011. Judge Gerhart currently presides over Division H, helps with District Court Juvenile matters and has been the County Court Presiding Judge since January 2021.