2024 Judicial Performance Evaluations - Full List
SUPREME COURT JUSTICES UP FOR RETENTION IN 2024
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Monica M. Márquez | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Maria E. Berkenkotter | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Brian D. Boatright | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
COURT OF APPEALS JUDGES UP FOR RETENTION IN 2024
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Gilbert M. Román | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Stephanie Dunn | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Jerry N. Jones | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable W. Eric Kuhn | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Timothy J. Schutz | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Jason D. Carrithers | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Diego G. Hunt | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Jefferson County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Bradley Allen Burback | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Verna L. Carpenter | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Keith Michael Goman | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Graham B. Peper | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Kristan Wheeler | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Gilpin County Court Judges up for Retention
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Mark T. Bailey | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Adam J. Espinosa | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Jay S. Grant | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Marie A. Moses | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Alex C. Myers | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Anita M. Schutte | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Stephanie Scoville | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Demetria E. Trujillo | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Denver County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable David Blackett | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Kelly C. Cherry | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Beth Faragher | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Renee A. Goble | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Isabel Pallares | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Nicole M. Rodarte | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Andre L. Rudolph | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Barry A. Schwartz | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Fran Simonet | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Theresa Spahn | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No District Court Judges up for Retention
No Huerfano County Court Judges up for Retention
No Las Animas County Court Judges up for Retention
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Eric Bentley | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Linda Margaret Billings-Vela | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Jill M. Brady | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Samuel Albert Evig | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Laura Norris Findorff | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Diana K. May | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable William H. Moller | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable David L. Shakes | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
El Paso County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Charlotte A. Ankeny | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Yolanda M. Fennick | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Shannon Marie Gerhart | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Steven Katzman | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Cynthia A. McKedy | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Teller County Court Judges up for Retention
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Rachel J. Olguin-Fresquez | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Clear Creek County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Cynthia J. Jones | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Eagle County Court Judges up for Retention
No Lake County Court Judges up for Retention
No Summit County Court Judges up for Retention
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Kim Soon Shropshire | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Archuleta County Court Judges up for Retention
No La Plata County Court Judges up for Retention
San Juan County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Anthony D. Edwards | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Steven Louis Schultz | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Keri A. Yoder | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Delta County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Bo A. Zeerip | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Gunnison County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Ashley Burgemeister | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Hinsdale County Court Judges up for Retention
Montrose County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Kurt Michael Beckenhauer | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Laura Harvell | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Ouray County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Lane P. Thomasson | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No San Miguel County Court Judges up for Retention
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Sarah B. Cure | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Joseph Dean Findley | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Jackson County Court Judges up for Retention
Larimer County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Kraig Ecton | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Joshua Blake Lehman | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Anne K. Norrdin | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Garfield County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Angela M. Roff | DOES NOT MEET PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Pitkin County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Ashley Andrews | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Rio Blanco County Court Judges up for Retention
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Tim O'Shea | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Pueblo County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Roberto Silva | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Margaret Vellar | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Kaitlin B. Turner | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Chaffee County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Diana C. Bull | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Custer County Court Judges up for Retention
No Fremont County Court Judges up for Retention
No Park County Court Judges up for Retention
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Kimberly D. Cortez | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Alamosa County Court Judges up for Retention
Conejos County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Jason Todd Kelly | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Costilla County Court Judges up for Retention
No Mineral County Court Judges up for Retention
Rio Grande County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable John W. Stenger | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Saguache County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Craig K. Schuenemann | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Carl S. McGuire III | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Justin B. Haenlein | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Robert James | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Kit Carson County Court Judges up for Retention
Logan County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Ray Ann Brammer | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Morgan County Court Judges up for Retention
Phillips County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Kimbra Killin | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Sedgwick County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Myka Marie Landry | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Washington County Court Judges up for Retention
Yuma County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Kristei Ray Jones | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No District Court Judges up for Retention
No Grand County Court Judges
No Moffat County Court Judges
Routt County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Erin M. Rowe Wilson | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Michael J. Davidson | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Baca County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Milla Lishchuk | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Cheyenne County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Deni Estelle Eiring | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Kiowa County Court Judges up for Retention
No Prowers County Court Judges up for Retention
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Samuel Scott Vigil | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Bent County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Lance P. Clark | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Crowley County Court Judges up for Retention
No Otero County Court Judges up for Retention
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Sharon Diane Holbrook | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Brett Martin | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Teri L. Vasquez | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Adams County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Courtney L. Dinnel | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Martin J. Flaum II | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Marques A. Ivey | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Madoche Jean | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Leroy D. Kirby | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Joshua T. Nowak | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Broomfield County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Amanda W. DeWick | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Benjamin Figa | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Ben L. Leutwyler III | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Robert R. Lung | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Bonnie Heather McLean | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Don Jesse Toussaint | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Shay K. Whitaker | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Joseph R. Whitfield Jr. | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Arapahoe County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Melina Hernandez | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Joshua Jay Williford | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Douglas County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Kelly Erin Waidler | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Elbert County Court Judges up for Retention
No Lincoln County Court Judges up for Retention
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Anita J. Crowther | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Allison J. Esser | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Todd L. Taylor | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Weld County Court Judges up for Retention
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable J. Keith Collins | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Robert R. Gunning | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Dea Marie Lindsey | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
| Honorable Thomas Francis Mulvahill | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
Boulder County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Jonathon P. Martin | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Twenty-First Judicial District Court Judges up for Retention
Mesa County Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Michael Joseph Grattan III | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
District Court Judges
| JUDGE NAME | COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION |
|---|---|
| Honorable Todd Jay Plewe | MEETS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS |
No Dolores County Court Judges up for Retention
No Montezuma County Court Judges up for Retention